Unpicking 5 More Feedback Policies



In 2010, Ross Morrison McGill started @TeacherToolkit from a simple Twitter account by way of which he promptly turned the ‘most followed teacher on social media in the UK’. In 2015, he was nominated as one particular of the ‘500 Most Influential People today in Britain’ by The Sunday…
Examine additional about @TeacherToolkit

How do university leaders lessen trainer workload while also enhancing instructing consistency?

Above the previous five a long time, I have rarely come across any school chief who tells me they have bulletproof consistency.

The above concern is a thing I have questioned myself for virtually 15 several years. I imagine some of our faculty insurance policies, even though on paper, wish to enhance consistency, frequently fail to reach it.

Last month, I unpicked 7 school feed-back/marking guidelines that I have been operating with to assistance move instructing and finding out dialogue into the next ten years. The unique concentration is to transfer absent from ‘marking’ and ‘feedback’, offering a tiny extra nuance for academics, mom and dad and pupils.

How ought to schools go forward?

I am at this time operating with 9 types of evaluation (together with marking) and 16 various influences that determine how effective your feed-back (into other forms: feed up and feedforward) to determine how successful your suggestions is been given.

After posting this video clip explanation, I received 5 new teaching and understanding guidelines from educational facilities. To secure the educational institutions and in purchase to increase consciousness and reward all, I’ve screenshot selected elements of the coverage and raised numerous questions to contemplate in your context.

Just before we go on, it is worthy of taking some supplemental data into account. The visuals beneath characterize one paragraph within a set of five files, ranging in between 3 to 16 webpages each. The highlighted sections discover a modest component where I have left a remark and responded to the college leader.

A short contextual statement is provided, then the picture, then a sequence of questions from me to look at.

College A

This faculty is based mostly in the Center East, UAE, and kinds a team of 8 academies for pupils aged 2 – 18 many years outdated.

Marking and Feedback Policy

  1. Why do most school insurance policies emphasis on marking, fairly than marking, feedback and non-verbal expectations?
  2. What are the positive aspects of marking work just about every two or a few weeks? If I were a maths teacher, I’ll see my students 4 or five periods a 7 days in comparison to the art teacher who may possibly just see their pupils the moment a 7 days. The curriculum should generate evaluation, not the other way about …
  3. What are the advantages of utilizing highlighter pens when responding to pupils’ function?
  4. Should evaluation only address blunders?
  5. How generally must a instructor history their assessments?


School B

This unbiased university is centered in the North of England. It is a modest pupil referral device for pupils (year 9 and higher than).

Marking and Feedback Policy

  1. How should verbal comments be referenced in subjects in which publications are rarely used in comparison to other people?
  2. Ought to verbal suggestions be referenced?
  3. How could you make a conversation express?
  4. Who need to have an understanding of the purpose of verbal feedback: the instructor or pupil?


College C

This is a big main college in South West England.

Marking and Feedback Policy

  1. The previous aspect of this document is a specific eyesight assertion, with snippets which include this bullet stage list. How could the university redesign the earlier mentioned bullet issue record to match the statements and expectations?
  2. If this coverage was redesigned to be shorter and punchy, for case in point, these 10 tips with a shorter sentence description pursuing each individual, how could the college make these statements a lot more explicit?
  3. Is there something lacking from the bullet factors, or would you get rid of any?


School D

This is a university based in South East England.

Marking and Feedback Policy

  1. We know college students ought to be taught how to present their perform, still we also know it is a bad proxy for mastering. Does your school’s plan involve information on presentation? Is ‘presentation’ really worth documenting?
  2. There are 4 coloured pens in the earlier mentioned coverage: How could we make this far more manageable for teachers and pupils?
  3. Ought to ‘presentation’ be component of a operate sampling system?


School E

This is a secondary university dependent in South West England. I have accomplished a variety of education classes with the school, and they have also been given Mark Strategy Train assets. Underneath is the opening assertion of their just one-web page summary.

Marking and Feedback Policy

  1. The faculty has composed or verbal comments, but there is no reference to non-verbal. Really should that be involved?
  2. Should really suggestions be reserved if pupils do not meet up with minimal requirements?
  3. How would “proportionate to curriculum time” purpose in your university plan?
  4. Reside marking is inspired. Is dwell comments inspired as well?
  5. How is progress about time monitored?
  6. What is the progress over time monitored? How do you observe verbal feedback?



I am a major enthusiast of obtaining a checklist of statements (see college C) and then defining these working with regular teacher education sessions with exemplar methods and ‘How to…’ assistance.

Of training course, we want information and descriptions, but I feel that ought to occur from normal qualified growth conversations among colleagues, somewhat than loads of ‘vision-like’ statements outlined in a policy that no person will examine.

In a technological period, the potential to depart voice recordings, acquire photos and leave opinions in the e-margin of paperwork working with an iPad is also well worth discovering.

Keep in mind, possessing penned 2 million words and phrases in 3,000 weblog posts on this website, the average reading time is 70 seconds – that tells you all you require to know about the doing the job practices of academics. Keep your plan concise!

If you would like access to some illustration policies, here are ~100 copies to use to build your personal template. One particular phrase of warning from me, really do not create it on your possess, involve all the educating workers in the method after you have the essential template in area …

If you would like me to give some critique on your educating and finding out plan, be sure to depart a comment below, e-mail or a social media DM …


Resource url

Natasha M. McKnight

Next Post

Pushpa Review | Pushpa: The Rise

Mon May 2 , 2022
Story: Pushpa Raj is a coolie who rises in the entire world of pink sandalwood smuggling. Along the way, he does not shy from earning an enemy or two. Assessment: With Pushpa: The Rise, Sukumar ventures into unchartered territory by generating a rustic masala film crammed with punch dialogues, people […]

You May Like